Nixon in China:
Sellar’s powerful revival of Nixon in China
by James Flanagan
When John Adams’ opera Nixon in China first premiered in 1987 there were, among the rave reviews, a handful of discerning critics who questioned the kindness with which history would treat it.
The lounge room historicism of the work, along with a musical tradition, American Minimalism, seen by many as nearing extinction, raised serious doubts about its potential. It is astonishing just how wrong those critics were.
Reuniting much of the original cast and crew - with James Maddalena reprising the Nixon role, and conducted by ENO's former artistic director Paul Daniel - Sellar's ENO revival of the much acclaimed 2000 production subtly enhances the opera's contemporary relevance.
The results are politically forceful but at times the production is let down by some surprisingly cluttered staging.
Most striking is the unexpected resonance Sellars finds in the current climate of Sino-American relations. Taken within the context of the late 1980s, when the work first premiered, Alice Goodman's libretto now seems dramatically lightweight.
When applied to the current relationship between America and China respectively, as well as the rest of the world, the character-driven investigation of Nixon's visit to China seems far more fitting.
In this production, Maddalena's Nixon, often a caricature in previous productions, assumes far greater status. Plagued by incertitude, this Nixon fully realises both the magnitude of his task and the obstacles his own personal shortcomings present in achieving them. The ENO programme is also helpful in explaining that the crucial subtext of Nixon’s visit was to press Mao to intervene in ending the war in South East Asia.
Sellars harnesses this crucial historical detail to portray a prophetic vision of America. The result is a fading and impotent imperial force begging the rising superpower to intervene in their disastrous recent forays abroad.
The dramatic power of the propaganda performance as witnessed by the Nixons on their second day has been greatly enhanced, as has the visceral presence of the Chinese government.
Mao's iconography and the mythological images of modern China dominate the scenery. At one point, Mao even emerges from a 40 foot image of his own head.
Modern China's rapid surge to global dominance can be felt throughout the production. But China is not portrayed as an object of suspicion or malevolence - instead we are lead to understand to engage with these changing times without fear.
The performances are all excellent. Janis Kelly's Pat Nixon is particularly impressive. Newcomer, Adrian Thompson also deserves special mention for the humour he brings to the rather unsympathetic portrayal of Kissinger.
But while the original production sought to harness the political relevance while highlighting the dramatic spectacle, this production aims for a more sparse, no-nonsense approach.
The spectacular aircraft arrival of Nixon is still there but with it is brought a surprising amount of shabbiness and there is a great deal of clutter on stage during the second and third acts.
Adams’ musical composition has lasted surprisingly well, considering just how over-utilised the American Minimalists have been in the preceding years. It is fascinating just how well the music fits the image of Maoist China.
Although the score does occasionally wander into the more banal Philip Glass end of minimalism, for the most part it provides an evocative and absorbing evening of music.
Despite its faults, Nixon remains an engaging night at the theatre. Most importantly, 'Nixon' possesses that rare commodity in what is too often the most conservative of the performing arts - dynamism and contemporary relevance.
|